FIP SREV AND GUIDELINES
FOR JUDGING THEMATIC PHILATELY EXHIBITS
In accordance with Article 1.4 of the General Regulations of the FIP for the Evaluation of Competitive Exhibits at FIP Exhibitions (GREV), the Special Regulations have been developed to supplement those principles with regard to thematic exhibits.
These Guidelines are issued by the FIP Thematic Commission to give practical advice on how to apply the GREV and incorporates the Special Regulations for the Evaluation of Thematic Exhibits (SREV)).
The Guidelines have been developed to assist exhibitors in the preparation and judges in the evaluation of thematic philately exhibits. They are intended to provide guidance regarding mainly:
- The definition of appropriate philatelic material to be used
- The principles of exhibit composition, and
- The judging criteria of exhibits of thematic philately.
Article 2: COMPETITIVE EXHIBITS
A thematic exhibit develops a theme according to a plan, as defined under 3.2.1, demonstrating thematic and philatelic knowledge through the items chosen.
Such knowledge should result in the best possible selection and arrangement of the material and the accuracy of the relevant thematic and philatelic text.
The texts of the whole exhibit must be written in any one of the FIP official languages (English, Spanish, German or French) (GREV art. 3.3).
Article 3: PRINCIPLES OF EXHIBIT COMPOSITION
3.1 Definition of Appropriate Philatelic Material
A thematic exhibit uses the widest range of appropriate postal-philatelic material (ref. GREV Art 3.2.)
Appropriate postal-philatelic material is that which has been issued, intended for issue, or produced in the preparation for issue, used, or treated as valid for postage by governmental, local or private postal agencies, or by other duly commissioned or empowered authorities for the purpose of transmitting mail or other postal communications.
Covers and other sort of mail usually have several characteristics: stamp(s), postmark(s), labels and markings indicating the special treatment of this mailing, and sometimes indications for postage privileges. These are the elements of postal origin and/or significance, which can be used for thematic treatment. Other characteristics of the same mailing, like sender’s name and address information, decorative printings or illustrations on the envelope / card, or the message and other parts of the content, are the non-postal (= private) elements which cannot be used for thematic treatment.
This distinction between postal elements and private elements (maybe on the same item which went through the post) is the one and only rule for defining appropriate philatelic material in thematic philately. Therefore, it is fundamental for understanding the nature of “postal-philatelic material” in thematic philately, in contrast to open class, which allows the private elements of the mail to be used.
Listings in this section of the guidelines are explanations of this rule.
Type of material
• Postal franking items (stamps, stamp booklets, postal stationery, franking meters, computer generated postage e.g. FRAMA labels, SmartStamps etc.)
• Modifications applied to postal franking items (overprints, surcharges, and punch- perforations, as shown by "perfins"). However, modified items are not to be included if the modification distracts from the original theme by making it no longer visible
• Postal cancellations (ordinary, slogan, commemorative and other special postmarks)
• Stamps, cancellations, marks and/or cards indicating a postage privilege (e.g. authorities, military)
• Other items used in the postal operations, such as registration labels, postal route labels and markings, supplementary labels or markings (e.g. censorship, disinfection, crash mail), mail delivery dockets, reply coupons, forwarding agents markings, postal automation markings and labels, etc.; where applicable, these items should be on the relevant document.
• Items "intended for issues, or produced in the preparation for an issue", e.g. sketches, proofs
• Varieties and errors
• Revenue stamps and stationery as long as they are postally used or have postage validity. Revenue stamps and stationery for fiscal purposes are admitted in exceptional cases, when they are the only mean to describe an important thematic point.
Time frame
Postal material from the pre-stamp era, through the classic period, to the present day.
Postal services
• Normal transmission of mail, including
o postage free service- and military- post including Airgraphs and V-mail;
o maritime mail,
o railway mail of any type
o air mail of any type
o prisoner-of-war and concentration camp mail
o packet, parcel post and freight post
• Postal payment service
• Private post, authorised or tolerated by the official authorities, or active in total absence of an official post
• Other postal communications, including
o pneumatic post
o telegrams
o electronic mail (i.e. message sent electronically to a Post Office where it is printed out and delivered to an addressee)
o other similar forms of postal services
Border-line material
The variety of postal services and regulations in different countries and their evolution over time make it impossible to define a list encompassing all possible situations. Items that only follow to a certain extent the above definitions of appropriate material should only be used when no other material is available to describe a specific thematic detail. When included in the exhibit, they should always be supported by a thorough philatelic justification.
Items belonging to the specific philatelic culture of a theme, a country or a region can be tolerated as much as they are justified and their number is proportional to the degree of elaboration of the exhibit.
The jury team shall evaluate borderline material primarily with regards to its thematic significance. It should never be shown solely for its rarity.
Inappropriate Material
The following items and the information made available by them should not be used for thematic development: A)
• fantasy issues from non-existent postal territories
• issues of exiled governments
• issues of organizations without postal services
• abusive, illegal and undesirable issues, as defined by the UPU and the FIP Philatelic Congress of 1976 (and available on the website of the FIP Fight against forgeries commission)
• picture postcards, unless they are postal stationery produced by a Postal Authority
B)
• private additional cancellations and cachets applied by a sender or a supplier before mailing
• private additional prints on postal stationery (also known as “repiquages”)
• administrative marks (not postal), when they do not give any postal privilege
• private decorations and decorative overprints on envelopes and cards
• private vignettes (advertising labels), whatever the purpose of their use
• privately printed or manuscript annotated military postcards and lettercards , unless accepted or authorized by Postal authorities as admitted to the postal privilege without other official markings
Aspects of category “B” are usually parts of mailings that bear postal elements like stamps and postmarks. These are the typical “private elements” of such mailings, which are usually not admitted for thematic treatment, as explained above. In exceptional cases (see also 4.2.2), where no postal-philatelic material for important aspects of the theme exists, the items under B) can be considered as borderline, i.e. acceptable items as long as they present a significant thematic connection and are supported by a thorough philatelic justification.
Thematic Information
Each item must be connected to the chosen theme and present its thematic information in the clearest and most effective way.
The thematic information used to illustrate the theme or tell a story is derived directly from the design or purpose of the issue or indirectly because analysis highlights the use of items that, at a first glance, do not show any connection with the theme.
This includes:
• issues that follow changes in political situations
• issues that document a particular period
• the design of the item, along with everything which is depicted or written on a stamp, postal stationery, postmark or other appropriate postal philatelic material.
• the text, art style of illustration and similar
• the material on which the item is printed, e.g., granite, silk thread, banknote paper, war maps
• the watermark design
• the perforation (e.g. "perfins")
• the text or illustration of margins, gutters, tabs, cover and interleaving of booklets
• functions of the postal service, which have a thematic significance (e.g. railway, telegraph, newspaper stamps, official service postal stationery, pigeon post)
The thematic information described above must be:
• initiated by the postal service, or
• introduced or added by the postal service (e.g. advertising appendices, marginal descriptions, postal stationery illustrations), or
• approved by the postal service (e.g. postal stationery to private order).
Printing or surcharges added privately after the sale of the items do not fulfil this requirement. Generic cancellations can be used because of
• the specific meaning of a place name, or
• the reason a place exists.
• Alternatively, they must contain adequate thematic information (e.g. advertising text, illustration), in addition to the data concerning the place and/or the date
A postmark, even if of the pre-philatelic period, does not document the birthplace of a person.
The postmark date and place, when related to a special event, which happened on the same date and place, is relevant only if
• other thematic elements help to illustrate the theme, or
• it has a specific thematic significance from a postal history standpoint; in the latter case it should only be used when it refers to an important detail of the theme.
Sender and addressee data represents insignificant information, unless
• the document shows a special postal privilege (e.g. reduced or free postage) as a result of the position, condition or status (e.g. military, government or other official mail) of one of the parties. The indication of reduced (or free) postage or the service postmarks, or equivalent markings of the postal route, provide sufficient evidence.
• In some cases sender and/or addressee data may be helpful as complementary thematic information, in combination with the postal elements of the document.
3.2 Thematic Treatment
The treatment of a thematic exhibit comprises the structure of the work (title and plan) and the elaboration of each point of that structure (development).
A thematic exhibit illustrates the theme chosen by the exhibitor, or better, tells a story related to this theme. The theme or story is presented in the thematic text and illustrated with appropriate philatelic material (see Article 1).
In thematic philately the plan represents the concept, as defined by the GREV. The two subdivisions Title and plan and Development represent the two aspects of an interlaced process, based on personal study and research by the collector on both the theme and the material:
• A deeper knowledge of the theme enables one to increase the number of facts and details described in the story and to look for additional items to illustrate them.
• A better knowledge of the material allows one to identify new pieces, which often must be justified through further study of the theme, which could result in a more elaborate plan.
The pages of an exhibit ought to present the chosen theme, as presented by the title and detailed in the plan, in its entirety, i.e. important parts of the chosen theme must not be omitted.
3.2.1 Title and Plan
The title and the plan must be presented on a title page at the beginning of the exhibit and written in any one of the official FIP languages.
The title page(s) at the start of the exhibit has:
• a title that clearly defines the theme
• a short introduction stating the purpose of the exhibit
• optionally information about the scope such as inclusions or omissions (major exclusions, however, should be clear from the title or subtitle)
• a plan that outlines the structure of the story
• an explanation of how rarity of items is shown within the exhibit
• a list of the most important philatelic references plus any personal research if appropriate
The title with any subtitle defines the scope of the exhibit. The title and the plan represent a meaningful entity and reflect the specific characteristics of the chosen theme. Hence, different titles originate different plans.
The title represents the synthesis of the exhibit. Therefore, the title, the plan and the contents of the pages must match, and the sequence of the philatelic items mounted on the pages should give the full details of the story implied by the title.
The plan defines the structure of the exhibit in a logical order of chapters and subchapters. Ideally the beginning of the following chapter has a logical link with that preceding. This helps to create an interesting story instead of an unconnected “list of contents". The best is when the chapters and subchapters are structured like a story. The plan should not have generic chapters such as Miscellaneous or Appendix, or subdivisions based on the type of philately such as Meters, Postal stationery or purpose of issue.
The different chapters should have a good balance, according to their relative thematic weight within the scope of the theme as defined by the title rather than by the quantity of material available. The plan describes all major subdivisions of the story. Finer subdivisions are presented on the individual pages. The plan cannot be replaced by a literary description or by a generic introductory statement. The structure of the plan may follow:
• a time-related classification (historical, evolutionary), or
• subject-related criteria (scientific, systematic, organisational, economic, etc.), or
• other subdivision criteria, in the case of themes related to Organisations and Institutions (e.g. Red Cross, League of Nations, Council of Europe), repetitive events (e.g. Stamp Days, Olympic Games), etc., such as:
o their structure,
o their type of organization
o individual events following thematically time- or place-related classifications.
A numerical classification (decimal, legal systems) is recommended, since it helps to make the exhibit easier to understand. It should be limited to major divisions of the plan. Experience has shown that a two/three digits/letters system is sufficient.
The construction of an innovative plan allows the exhibitor to implement an innovative development and create a more distinctive exhibit.
See Art. 4.1.1 for how this criterion is evaluated
3.2.2 Development
The development means to elaborate the theme in depth, aiming to achieve a consistency between title, plan and the pages of exhibit.
The analysis of both the theme and the appropriate material, based on a thorough thematic and philatelic knowledge, is a prerequisite for the best possible thematic development. This enables the skilful selection of each item and its correct positioning and sequence, as well as a connecting description.
This is shown by:
• the selection of the most suitable items for each thematic detail described.
• the balanced utilisation of the items according to the significance of the thematic detail they support. The number of philatelic items available for the same detail should not be the basis for their inclusion.
• the accurate thematic arrangement of the items shown on the same page according to the sequence of the story. The correct sequence takes priority over the best appearance of the page.
• an easy to understand, fluent thread with the story developed on pages and flowing through the exhibit like a book
Page headings may help to indicate which part of the plan is on the page
See Art. 4.1.2 for how this criterion is evaluated
3.3 Knowledge
3.3.1 Thematic knowledge
Thematic knowledge is demonstrated by the telling of the story illustrated by the correct thematic material. A deeper knowledge of the theme enables one to increase the number of facts and details described in the story and to look for additional items to illustrate them. Thematic text should be spread over each page, placed near the item illustrating that part, and read from left to right and top to bottom.
Correct, appropriate and concise thematic text should link the philatelic material to the story. It:
• illustrates the logical sequence of the development, by connecting the items shown. A good connection is effective and concise, without unnecessary information. This requires that the text is fluid enough to demonstrate the thread of the development.
• provides a short thematic description whenever the connection between the item and the theme is not self-explanatory. Gives appropriate information of the thematic details of stamps and documents.
Items that do not have a demonstrated relationship with the theme should not be forced into the story even if they are good philatelic items.
Any thematic explanation has to be closely related to the material shown, and any given statement must be supported by thematically appropriate philatelic items, otherwise, it weakens the thematic development.
See Art. 4.2.1 for how this criterion is evaluated
3.3.2 Philatelic Knowledge
The material displayed should be fully consistent with the subject chosen, and a good knowledge of philatelic material allows one to select the most suitable items and to identify new pieces. The selection should show the appreciation of the exhibitor as to what is available in the context of his chosen subject. It should also include the fullest range of relevant philatelic material of the highest available quality (GREV, Art. 3.4).
When selecting qualified material for the exhibit, preference and greater importance must be given to:
• types of items that are the cornerstone of philately (i.e. stamps, postal stationery, cancellations and postmarks) as opposed to items with a lower postal connotation, even if their issue or use has been duly authorised by the post
• issues that bear a direct relation to the issuing country from a political, historical, cultural, economic and/or similar standpoint. Speculative issues and the ones not following the code of ethics of the UPU shall be avoided
• normal issues, as opposed to additional parallel imperforate issues (stamps and souvenir sheets)
• genuinely cancelled items, as opposed to items cancelled to order
• genuinely carried commercial mail with relevant cancellations, as opposed to items created for collectors, e.g. decorated FDCs (even when issued by the postal service), and maximum cards
• genuinely carried items with correct postage and relevant thematic cancellations, as opposed to favour cancellations, often with underfranked postage, or, even worse, cancellations on stampless covers (“blank cancellations”) unless due to a free postage privilege
• mail with correct postage frankings, preferably as multiple franking of a thematically important stamp, as opposed to overfrankings due to philatelic reasons (e.g. complete sets)
• meter frankings with correct postage, as opposed to favour cancellations (e.g. “000”), unless the latter is a "specimen" or it has a justified postal reason.
Common stamps and documents are appropriate if they best represent important thematic details. The relative rarity or unusual characteristics of proofs, varieties and similar items, can increase the philatelic quality of the exhibit.
Common varieties (e.g. minor colour nuances) play an insignificant role and may adversely affect the thematic development. If a variety does not clearly demonstrate the connection with the theme, the normal item should be also shown as a reference.
The use of maximum cards should be limited to a few, significant items, to enhance the understanding of the thematic information, if this is too tiny to be properly seen on the stamp. In addition to the necessary concordance of subject, time and date, defined in the principles of Maximaphily, these items should have a theme-related cancellation.
The use of revenue stamps and stationery for fiscal purposes should be limited to some significant items, mainly to enhance the thematic development in very important points of the theme that cannot be covered otherwise.
Exceptions to the above criteria may only be shown if properly justified. A short explanation is required only when the material is not self-explanatory or there is a need to illustrate special research. In particular, philatelic text can be used when a specific philatelic characteristic of the item is not easily recognizable, for documenting the use of revenue stamps, for proper identifying borderline items or for presenting a philatelic study. Boosting definitions, in the style of those of the auction-catalogues, are inappropriate.
Ideally there should be a different font or style (like italic etc.) to distinguish the philatelic text from the thematic one.
One or more philatelic studies should be included when appropriate, to show higher philatelic knowledge. Postal items and documents present a number of philatelic variants. If this material is of thematic and philatelic importance, then a concise and balanced philatelic study is commendable, so that this material can be properly shown.
A philatelic study follows in a systematic manner the criteria for traditional philately (e.g. development of the item, varieties), postal history (e.g. usage, routes, handling of the mail, postmarks) or any other postal philatelic discipline. A philatelic study may exploit existing sources for further personal research. In order to safeguard the balance of the exhibit, the aim of these studies is not completeness, but the presence of the most significant philatelic peculiarities.
The extent of the studies is proportional to the degree of specialisation of the exhibit.
Philatelic studies, whenever included, blend with the thematic development without affecting the fluidity of elaboration of the exhibit. The thematic text has to continue in parallel with the study, so that there is no disturbing interruption.
See Art. 4.2.2 for how this criterion is evaluated.
3.4 Presentation
The presentation and the accompanying text of the exhibit should be simple, tasteful and well balanced (GREV Art. 3.4).
See Art. 4.4 for hints on how this criterion is evaluated.
3.5 One Frame Exhibits
A One Frame exhibit of Thematic Philately is intended to be an exhibit with a very narrow theme that fits into one frame. If a theme can be shown in more than one frame, it is not suitable as a theme for a One Frame exhibit.
A selection of items from a multi-frame exhibit may be suitable only if the selection can completely treat a natural sub-theme of the exhibit within one frame. An extract of a multi-frame exhibit showing only the best items ("cherry picking") from a multi-frame exhibit is not appropriate as a One Frame exhibit.
Article 4: CRITERIA FOR EVALUATION
The general criteria, as specified in GREV Art. 4, are adapted to the peculiarities of the thematic class.
The thematic jurors must complete an evaluation form in order to be guided towards a thorough, unbiased and consistent judging.
In order to help consistent judging, within all of the following evaluation criteria, except for Presentation, there is a distinction between Basic requirements and Achievements.
Basic requirements. When all of them are fulfilled a score equal to 80% of the maximum is assigned. When any of them is not fulfilled, a mistake occurs and the 80% score is reduced accordingly.
Achievements. These requirements are gradual goals on the road to make the exhibit outstanding. They are worth >80% of the maximum and the fulfilment of all of them implies the top score.
4.1 Thematic Treatment (30 points)
Treatment will be evaluated according to the title and the plan, as well as the development. Treatment is the presentation of the story for the theme chosen and its development throughout the pages, both showing an innovative approach.
In assessing treatment judges are looking for:
• A logical development that is easy to follow
• A clear and concise write up
• A balanced exhibit for the theme chosen
• The degree to which the plan tells a story They will check that the exhibit:
• Reflects the theme as defined by the title
• Is developed in accordance with the plan
• Has new aspects and new approaches for known themes, or develops a new theme.
4.1.1 Title and Plan (10 points)
The title and the plan will be evaluated considering the:
• consistency between the plan and the title
• presence of the plan page
• adequacy of the plan page
• correct, logical and balanced structure (divisions and subdivisions)
• coverage of all major aspects necessary to develop the theme.
Judges will primarily be looking for:
• a title that defines the overall concept, that is structured through the plan.
• a clear and concise purpose and scope that outlines the theme and justifies any exclusions
• consistency between the title and the plan
• a correct, logical and balanced structuring into divisions and sub-divisions i.e.
o Correct: The plan is accurate, scientifically reliable and sound
o Logical: The sequence of the main chapters and their subdivisions must follow a rational order, without superfluous or misplaced sections
o Balanced: The importance given to the different sections shall be in accordance with the thematic significance.
The plan page, that provides an insight into the theme, has to be shown at the beginning of the exhibit. Failure to do so will result in the automatic loss of three points.
The best plans are those in which the chapters (and their subdivisions) are structured to tell a story and are evaluated much higher than those structured like a “list of contents".
Title and plan will be evaluated considering:
Basic requirements
• presence of the plan page
• adequacy of the plan page
• consistency between the plan and the title
• correct, logical and balanced structure (divisions and subdivisions)
• coverage of all major aspects necessary to develop the theme Achievements
• degree to which the plan tells a story
• innovation, by showing an original approach in the chosen structure of the exhibi
4.1.2 Development (20 points).
The development will be evaluated considering the:
• correct assembly and positioning of the items in conformity with the plan
• connection between the items and the thematic text
• depth, shown through connections, cross references, ramifications, causes and effects
• balance, by giving to each thematic point the importance corresponding to its significance within the theme
• elaboration of all aspects of the plan.
Judges will primarily be looking for:
• The storyline as presented by the plan is developed on the pages and written as a continuous story flowing through each page. It should be read as in a book from top left to bottom right.
• Pages should have headers stating the relevant chapter (or subchapter) in order to indicate which part of the plan is being developed on the page. An additional title of each page, summarizing its specific content, is also helpful.
• The correct assembly and position of the items is demonstrated by a well understood, correct, and fluent thread of development. Items should be placed near the thematic text related to them.
• The balance is demonstrated by giving the appropriate depth and size to the various thematic details, according to their significance within the theme. This also applies to philatelic studies.
Development will be evaluated considering: Basic requirements
• correct assembly and positioning of the items in conformity with the plan
• connection between the items and the thematic text
• elaboration of all aspects of the plan
• presence of a “red thread” that connects the single pages and chapters into a continuous story Achievements
• balance, by giving to each thematic point the importance corresponding to its significance within the theme
• depth, shown through connections, cross references, ramifications, causes and effects
• innovation, by showing an original approach in the treatment of the chosen subject
4.2 Knowledge, Personal Study and Research (35 points)
The GREV considers “philatelic and related knowledge”, that can be seen as the result of two components:
• A “concept” related knowledge. In almost all classes is of postal and philatelic nature: issues, usages, printing processes, rates, routes, services, and so on. In thematic philately this “concept” is of a thematic nature: cars, bridges, history, nature, sport, etc.; hence “thematic knowledge” is that which is based on personal study and research and sound knowledge of the theme studied.
• “Philatelic knowledge”, that relates to the selection of the appropriate material used to support the concept, as well as the correct description of it when needed. This component is common to all classes.
4.2.1 Thematic Knowledge, and its related Personal Study and Research (15 points)
Thematic Knowledge, and its related Personal Study and Research will be evaluated considering the
• appropriateness, conciseness and correctness of the thematic text
• correct thematic use of the material
• presence of new thematic findings for the theme.
Judges will primarily be looking for:
• thematic knowledge shown in the choice of the items to cover specific thematic details, and their mutual relationship
• the appropriateness of the accompanying text
• the absence of thematic errors
• the presence of material directly connected with the theme, avoiding doubtful, or unnecessary borderline items.
• the use of “surprising” material, that is thematically appropriate, even if not immediately seen from the material alone, but whose appropriateness was discovered by the exhibitor.
Thematic study and research is demonstrated by the use of available thematic and philatelic literature, catalogues and documented research as well as any personal research and study shown by the exhibitor.
Thematic Knowledge will be evaluated considering:
Basic requirements
• appropriate, concise and correct thematic text
• correct use of thematic material Achievements
• thematic details in text and material
• presence of new thematic findings for the chosen theme
• “surprising” material (that does not belong to the subject, but thematically fits the story)
4.2.2 Philatelic Knowledge, and its related Personal Study and Research (20 points).
Philatelic Knowledge, Personal Study and Research will be evaluated considering the
• full compliance with the rules of postal philately
• presence of the widest possible range of postal-philatelic material and its balanced use
• appropriateness of postal documents
• appropriateness and correctness of philatelic text, when required
• presence of philatelic studies and related skilful use of important philatelic material.
Judges will primarily be looking for:
• presence of appropriate postal-philatelic material with real philatelic significance
• full compliance with the rules of postal philately, i.e. no presence of items that are unsuitable for collecting purposes because of their state (e.g. cut stamps or cut postal stationery, improper maximum cards).
• postal-philatelic items (e.g. stamps, postal stationery, proofs, artworks) are shown in their entirety. Exceptions are windowing of cancellations; overlapping varieties of postal stationery as long as the variety is clearly visible; windowing large items.
• presence and balanced utilisation of varied philatelic types of material
• presence of material from of a variety of periods (pre-philately to modern), and from many countries, within the possibilities of the chosen theme
• limited use of borderline items (as indicated in section 3.1), at most one per frame on average, where the item significantly enhances the thematic text or is the only way to illustrate it. Such items must be fully justified as exceptions, thus proving the philatelic knowledge of the exhibitor. Higher flexibility may be used in case borderline items are part of a philatelic study.
Personal philatelic study and research are demonstrated by the presence of:
• material which has not yet been researched for that theme, or where there has been very little research
• philatelic studies presenting a true, well documented, philatelic in-depth analysis (i.e. such studies shall not be an excuse for showing an accumulation of more pieces without any serious philatelic foundation).
Philatelic Knowledge will be evaluated considering:
Basic requirements
• Full compliance with the rules of postal philately
• Appropriateness of postal documents
• Appropriateness and correctness of the philatelic text, when needed
• Presence of good range of postal-philatelic material throughout the exhibit Achievements
• Presence of widest possible range of postal-philatelic material and its balanced use
• Presence of material which has not yet been researched for that theme, or where there has been very little research
• Presence of philatelic studies and skilful use of important philatelic material
4.3 Condition and Rarity (30 points)
The criteria of "Condition and Rarity" require an evaluation of the quality of the displayed material considering the standard of the material that exists for the chosen subject, the rarity and the relative difficulty of acquisition of the selected material.
4.3.1 Rarity (20 points)
The rarity is based on objective criteria such as recognised absolute scarcity and difficulty of acquisition.
It is essential that varieties, proofs, essays, are rarer than the issue itself, in order to increase the philatelic level. The same applies to blocks, strips, etc.
It is obvious that items which, despite being very rare, have no or insufficient relationship to the theme, should not be included in the evaluation of this criterion.
Judges will primarily be looking for:
• rarities of philatelic significance with sufficient relationship to the theme
• known rarities of specific significance for the chosen theme
• the presence of varieties, essays, proofs, strips and blocks that are rarer than the issue itself,
• scarce and uncommon items, particularly from traditional philately, postal history and postal stationery
• how difficult it is to duplicate the exhibit Rarity will be evaluated considering:
Basic requirements
• Normal and modern material plus unusual and scarce items Achievements
• Presence of rare items
4.3.2 Condition (10 points)
The condition is based on the usual overall criteria for evaluation in philately and is related to the degree of rarity of the items present in the exhibit.
All items should be in the best possible condition. The condition of items is evaluated as if they were stamps: No tears, no missing corners, no bends, no stains, no missing perforations (if present), etc.
• The condition of common material should be impeccable.
• The actual condition obtainable will vary according to the country and period.
• Exhibitors may show unique or very rare material that is not in fine condition but are cautioned from including other items in a condition that may reduce the perceived overall condition.
• Commercially used items are to be preferred to philatelic produced ones.
• Cancellations should be as clear as possible with all essential wording complete and allow the stamp design, where thematically relevant, to be clearly visible.
• Booklets should be presented complete with stamps.
• If an item has been restored or manipulated, it must be described as such. Condition will be evaluated considering:
Basic requirements
• Normal and modern material in excellent quality, plus all unusual in good quality and rare material in average condition
Achievements
• Rarities in above average up to best quality
4.4 Presentation (5 points)
The criterion of “Presentation” requires an evaluation of the:
• clarity of the display
• clarity of the text
• the overall aesthetic balance of the exhibit.
The method of presentation should show the material to the best effect and in a balanced way, both on the sheet, in the frames and throughout the whole exhibit.
The presentation of the exhibit is evaluated on:
• The arrangement of items and text on appropriate exhibition pages effectively communicates the story and highlights the philatelic material in an attractive and aesthetic way.
• Overall aesthetic balance on the frames and the individual pages
• Good use of the page – without too much blank space
• The write-up is clear and concise and relevant to the material chosen and the exhibit subject, avoiding too much text on the pages
• Photocopies and scans must be a minimum of 25% different in size from the original
• Careful and neat mounting, e.g. large items should not be mounted at an angle or on their side
No advantage or disadvantage shall apply as to whether the text is handwritten, typewritten or printed. Brightly coloured inks and coloured album pages should be avoided.
Article 5: JUDGING OF THE EXHIBITS
5.1. Thematic exhibits will be judged by the approved specialists in their respective field and in accordance with the section V, Art. 31 to 46, of the GREX (ref.: GREV, Art. 5.1).
The thematic jurors must complete an evaluation form in order to be guided towards a thorough and consistent judgement.
5.2. For thematic exhibits, the following relative terms are presented to lead the Jury to a balanced
evaluation (ref.: GREV, Art. 5.3).
- 1. Treatment 30
- Title and Plan 10
- Development 20
- 2. Knowledge, Personal Study and Research 35
- Thematic 15
- Philatelic 20
- 3. Condition and Rarity 30
- Condition 10
- Rarity 20
- 4. Presentation 5
- TOTAL 100
The presence of faked, forged or repaired items, which are not clearly marked as such, will cause the downgrading of the exhibit by the Jury, according to the report of the special Expert Team appointed at each exhibition.
Reprints must be presented as such. Weak or faded postmarks must not be redrawn on piece; instead a copy of the postmark should be redrawn and presented next to the original.
Collectors are therefore recommended to have any doubtful item expertised before selecting it for the exhibit and the original of the certificates should be included behind the sheet, in the same transparent protective cover. In case a photocopy is used, the same has to be certified by the Federation. Alternatively, the commissioner may bring the original certificate for use if needed. Irrelevant of how the certificate is made available, at the end of the philatelic text concerning the item certified should be put the abbreviation “e” in bold thus (e).
Article 6: CONCLUDING PROVISIONS
6.1 In the event of any discrepancies in the text arising from translation, the English text shall prevail.
6.2 These Special Regulations (SREV) and Guidelines were approved at the FIP Thematic Commission held online, February 14th, 2026, and subsequently approved by the FIP Board on September 8th, 2026. They come into force on September 8th, 2026, and apply to exhibitions starting from January 1st, 2027.

No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario